Is a Housing Market Crash Coming? Latest Expert Opinions

The real estate world is always changing, and everyone wonders if a housing market crash is coming. Recent data and forecasts give us clues about the market's current state. They also highlight the risks and chances ahead.

Earlier this year, the S&P CoreLogic Case-Shiller Home Price Index showed a 4.96% rise in home prices by July 2024. Fannie Mae predicts a 6.1% increase in home prices for 2024 and a 3% increase for 2025. The Mortgage Bankers Association sees a 3.9% increase by the end of 2024 and a 2.7% increase by the end of 2025.

The National Association of Realtors estimates home prices will hit around $398,700 by the end of 2024. They predict prices will reach $405,000 by the end of 2025.

These numbers show a housing market with steady, but slowing, price growth. Yet, the fast rise in home prices worries some experts. They fear a housing bubble might be forming. It's important to understand the market's dynamics and the different views of industry experts.

Current State of the Housing Market

The housing market in the United States has seen big changes lately. Existing home sales and mortgage demand have shown clear trends. Existing home sales have hit their lowest since 2010, showing a slowdown.

This drop is mainly due to high mortgage rates. Rates have more than doubled from 2020 and 2021. Also, high home prices play a big role.

Existing Home Sales and Mortgage Demand

The National Association of Realtors (NAR) reports a drop in existing home sales. They've fallen to their lowest since 2010. This decline is closely tied to a drop in mortgage demand.

As mortgage rates have soared, reaching 7.79% in October 2023, many find buying homes less affordable. This has led to a delay or pause in homebuying plans for many.

Impact of High Mortgage Rates and Home Prices

High mortgage rates and home prices make it tough for buyers. The average home value in the United States is $217,961, as of February 2024. This is with a six-month change of -$587.

This shows home prices are still high but might be easing in some areas. Yet, the high cost of financing makes homeownership a big challenge for many Americans.

As the housing market changes, watching these trends is key. It's important to see how they affect access to affordable housing for people and families.

Housing Market Crash: Expert Opinions

Experts have different views on the housing market's future. Some see signs of a housing bubble, like fast price rises and investors. But most housing economists don't think a big crash will happen in 2024 or 2025.

Consensus Among Housing Experts

Experts say the market is strong because of strict lending rules and homeowners' financial health. According to industry sources, there's hope for a stable market. They think a crash in 2025 is unlikely.

Signs of a Potential Housing Bubble

But, different areas and local trends might face bigger price drops. Places with big price jumps during the pandemic could see prices fall with more homes and less demand.

"The current mortgage rates and tight supply indicate market stability, but regional variations and local trends could still lead to more significant price adjustments in certain areas."

Despite some hurdles, experts don't see a crash as bad as 2008. A price drop could make homes more affordable. But, staying financially stable is key for both buyers and sellers. Keeping up with local trends and economic signs is wise for making smart housing market choices.

Factors Contributing to Housing Market Stability

Despite worries about a housing market crash, there are key factors keeping it stable. Strict lending rules and homeowners' built-up equity are major reasons. These have been in place since the last big financial crisis.

Stringent Lending Standards

The housing market's strength comes from strict lending rules after 2008. Lenders now ask for better credit scores, bigger down payments, and proof of steady income. This means only more qualified people can get loans, lowering the risk of defaults and foreclosures.

Homeowner Equity and Healthier Balance Sheets

Homeowners' equity is also a big plus for the market. As home prices go up, so does the wealth in homes. This wealth acts as a safety net against market ups and downs. It makes homeowners less likely to default on their loans, keeping them in their homes.

Together, strict lending and homeowners' equity make the housing market's balance sheet healthier. This stability means the market can keep growing steadily and safely.

Cautious Building Practices and Supply Chain Disruptions

Builders have become more careful, focusing on building homes based on demand. This approach has helped avoid the over-supply problems that led to the 2008 housing market crash. But, supply chain disruptions and economic issues have made it hard for builders to quickly increase the number of homes. This could help make homes more affordable.

Global economic uncertainty has grown due to many factors. These include the 2007–2008 Global Financial Crisis, Brexit, US-China trade tensions, the COVID-19 pandemic, and the Russia–Ukraine war in 2022. These events have negatively affected commercial property, making it harder to invest.

Developers see a chance to start new projects in Q4 2024 and Q1 2025. This is because there's a lot of supply and not enough demand, which could lower costs. But, the housing supply and new home construction are still limited by supply chain issues and cautious building.

The commercial real estate market is expected to stay in a high-rate environment for a while. There's a lot of money waiting to be used for projects. Developers want to start projects soon to find better deals and save money. But, the housing supply and new home construction will likely stay low due to cautious building and supply chain problems.

"Developers in specific submarkets and asset classes anticipate a unique window of opportunity in Q4 2024 and Q1 2025 due to high supply and low demand conditions, potentially reducing costs."

Demographic Demand: Millennials and Gen Z

The housing market is seeing a big increase in demand. This is thanks to millennials and Gen Z. Millennials, aged 28 to 43, are now buying homes in large numbers. Today, 51.5% of them own a home.

Millennials are the largest and most tech-savvy group of homebuyers. They use mobile devices and virtual tools more than older generations. Over half of them are okay with making an offer on a home they've seen online. And 39% are comfortable buying a home online.

Gen Z, aged 12 to 27, is also starting to look for homes. With 25 million potential buyers, the demand for housing will stay strong.

Student debt and affordability issues have slowed some millennials. But their large size and Gen Z's entry will keep housing demand high.

Limited Housing Supply and Its Impact

The housing market is still recovering from the Great Recession. A big reason is the limited housing supply. In 2007, there were 98,067 residential construction firms. By 2012, this number dropped to 48,557, a 50% fall.

Single-family housing starts returned to pre-recession levels in 2020. But, existing home sales fell by 16% in late 2022 due to high mortgage rates. This limited supply has kept home prices high, with only 4.2 months of inventory as of August 2024.

This limited supply makes homes hard to afford. In 2023, bidding wars made it tough for most U.S. households to afford 16% of home listings.

Experts say adding more housing too fast without demand could lead to a market crash. The construction industry faces supply chain issues and fewer job openings. Finding a balance in the housing market is uncertain.

"The limited housing supply, partly due to slower building rates and supply chain disruptions, has played a role in maintaining home values. While this has posed challenges for affordability, it has also prevented a sudden drop in home prices that could trigger a market crash."

To fix this, some cities are changing zoning laws and cutting builder costs. This aims to increase housing supply. But, solving this issue will need a complex solution.

1. New residential construction starts for privately-owned housing in August 2024 were up 9.6% from the previous month and 3.9% year-over-year, indicating some improvement in housing starts.
2. The supply of homes for sale in the U.S. reached a record low of 1.6 months in January 2022, as per the National Association of Realtors (NAR). By August 2024, the housing supply had increased to 4.2 months, but it was still insufficient to meet demand.
3. Large investors bought 14.8% of homes on the market in the first quarter of 2024, a record-high percentage, further limiting the available housing inventory for individual buyers.

The housing market faces many challenges, with limited supply being a key factor. It affects homeowners, buyers, and the economy in both good and bad ways.

Economic Recovery and Job Market Strength

The U.S. economy is bouncing back after tough years. The job market's strength is key to keeping the housing market stable. Growth in key sectors and lower unemployment boost consumer confidence and housing demand.

The job market has shown great strength. Unemployment fell to 4.1% in September 2024. This means more people can afford homes, helping the housing market. Also, more jobs and higher wages are good for the housing sector.

The Federal Reserve's interest rate moves are important for recovery. Even with rate hikes to fight inflation, the chance of cuts soon boosts market confidence. With steady job growth, the housing sector looks stable despite broader economic challenges.

Despite some challenges, the housing market looks stable thanks to economic recovery and job growth. As people feel more confident and have more money, they'll keep wanting homes. This supports the housing market's health.

Policy Interventions and Regulations

The housing market is facing uncertainty, and government actions are crucial. Adjusting interest rates and starting homeowner help programs can make homes more affordable. These steps also prevent the rise of speculative bubbles that could cause a crash.

Working with the private sector to improve tax incentives and support new construction is key. The Task Force plans to release a national policy agenda soon. This will guide the next administration's first 100 days.

Learning from past housing market crashes is vital. We aim to increase oversight and protect consumers. Our goal is to ensure the housing industry is transparent, fair, and safe from future crises.

If you want to know other articles similar to Is a Housing Market Crash Coming? Latest Expert Opinions You can visit the category Real Estate.